BAKU - Remarks by an Armenian politician at a forum in Moscow have renewed debate over contradictions in Azerbaijan-Russia relations and the continued rejection of postwar realities by some Russian political circles.
Azerbaijani political analyst Ilgar Velizade, who heads the South Caucasus Political Scientists Club, said some forces in Russia have not accepted the changes that followed Azerbaijan’s restoration of control over Karabakh. Moscow officially recognizes Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity, but figures in Russia’s political and media sphere continue to make statements challenging the regional order, he said in an interview with the Daily Europe Online YouTube channel.
The discussion followed an appearance by Eduard Sharmazanov, a former deputy speaker of Armenia’s parliament and a member of the Republican Party, at the international “For the Freedom of Nations” forum in Moscow. Sharmazanov described Karabakh as “occupied,” accused Azerbaijan of ethnic cleansing of Armenians in 2023 and demanded the release of former leaders of the Karabakh separatist structures who are being held in Baku.
Those claims represented the Armenian opposition politician’s position, not an officially announced position of the Russian state. Velizade nevertheless said the decision to provide a platform for such remarks raises questions in light of existing agreements between Azerbaijan and Russia.
Azerbaijan-Russia Declaration
Velizade pointed to the Declaration on Allied Interaction signed by Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Vladimir Putin on Feb. 22, 2022. The document commits the two countries to respect each other’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and the inviolability of state borders.
He highlighted Clause 11, under which both sides undertake to prevent organizations and individuals on their territory from acting against the sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity of the other country. Clause 18 provides for cooperation against terrorism, extremism and separatism.
Velizade said Sharmazanov’s remarks were contrary to the political spirit of those commitments and that Baku was entitled to ask why demands affecting Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity were voiced at a Russian venue.
The holding of the forum and the Armenian politician’s appearance do not, by themselves, prove that Russian authorities violated the declaration. Such a conclusion would require establishing the nature of the organizers’ involvement and responsibility.
Different Views Inside Russia
Velizade said the issue went beyond a single speech. In his assessment, influential groups in Russia’s political and information space remain hostile to the changed situation in Karabakh. Some members of those circles continue to hold responsible positions, take part in political debates and appear on federal television.
Russia officially recognizes Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan, but that does not mean every political force in the country accepts the outcome of the conflict in the same way. Velizade said this divergence between interstate documents and the statements of individual political figures complicates ties between Baku and Moscow, even as both governments publicly seek normalization.
Baku’s Cooperation With NATO
The debate came as Hikmet Hajiyev, an aide to Azerbaijan’s president, visited Brussels. On Nov. 16, he met NATO’s Deputy Permanent Representatives Committee in a NATO-Azerbaijan format to discuss the results of cooperation, regional security and prospects for further engagement.
Hajiyev said Azerbaijan has cooperated with the alliance since 1994 and wants to continue political dialogue and practical partnership.
Velizade cautioned against portraying the Brussels meeting as an immediate response to the Moscow forum. Azerbaijan’s contacts with NATO are planned in advance and form part of a long-term relationship, he said. Still, he added that changing regional conditions require some areas of cooperation with Western partners to be reviewed, including security, military education, logistics and transport infrastructure.
Velizade rejected the idea that broader NATO ties meant Azerbaijan intended to change its military-political status. Baku does not plan to join the alliance or become part of a security system directed against Russia or Iran, he said.
Azerbaijan has consistently avoided bloc confrontation because such a policy could turn the country into a buffer between competing centers of power, he said. Instead, Baku develops relations with Turkey, European countries, Russia, China and Central Asian states, leaving room for independent decisions. He also noted that Azerbaijan restored its territorial integrity without being a NATO member.
Mehdiyev Case and Russia
The interview also addressed former Azerbaijani presidential administration chief Ramiz Mehdiyev. The host asked whether his case could be connected to Baku-Moscow relations.
Velizade urged caution. Even if investigators found contacts with the Russian side, that would not be sufficient to conclude that Moscow supported Mehdiyev’s alleged plans, he said. Velizade said he knew of no evidence that Russian official bodies responded positively to any such approaches and argued against viewing the case solely through the lens of Azerbaijani-Russian confrontation.
China and a New Division of Influence
Velizade also rejected suggestions that Washington, Moscow and Beijing could agree on a new division of the world resembling the 1945 Yalta Conference. Today’s international system includes independent regional powers such as India, Turkey and Saudi Arabia, as well as Central Asian states with interests of their own, he said.
China, in his view, favors long-term partnerships and economic ties over a formal division of the world into spheres of influence. He described Russian-Chinese relations primarily as a strategic partnership, not a military-political alliance with NATO-style obligations.
A Regional Security System Without New Dividing Lines
Velizade said Azerbaijan favors a regional security system without new dividing lines and believes lasting security in the South Caucasus cannot be achieved by completely excluding a major neighboring state from regional processes.
That position does not mean abandoning cooperation with Western governments or international organizations, he said. Baku intends to determine its relationship with each partner independently, based on national interests and regional conditions.
In Velizade’s assessment, Azerbaijan’s closer contacts with NATO and its continued relationship with Russia are not mutually exclusive. But statements such as those heard at the Moscow forum show that political disputes over Karabakh continue to affect Azerbaijan’s relations with some Russian political circles after the end of the armed conflict.
Source: Vesti Baku.